Story Summary
Pucking Around is a slow-burn, why-choose hockey romance that blends sports, spice, and emotional depth. It follows Rachel Price, a newly minted physical therapist for the Jacksonville Rays — a professional hockey team — as she navigates her career, her confidence, and her very complicated love life.
Rachel is still recovering from a bad breakup and determined to stay professional. But that plan doesn't last long when she finds herself tangled up with not one but three hockey players:
- Jake "Bucks" Bouchard, the team's captain and all-around golden retriever of a man.
- Liam "Scotty" Doyle, the charming goofball defenseman who hides his depth behind humor.
- Aiden "Murph" Murphy, the intense goalie with a quiet fire and protective streak.
As friendships blur into something more, Rachel learns to trust again — not just the men who love her but herself. It's funny, emotional, and unapologetically steamy, proving love doesn't have to fit one mold.
Main Characters
Rachel Price
- Age: 26
- Hair Color: Blonde
- Eye Color: Green
- Identity: Sports physical therapist
Smart, sarcastic, and fiercely independent — learning to find her place in love and life again.
Jake "Bucks" Bouchard
- Age: 30
- Hair Color: Brown
- Eye Color: Blue
- Identity: Team captain / power forward
The classic golden boy — steady, kind, and hopelessly in love with Rachel.
Liam "Scotty" Doyle
- Age: 28
- Hair Color: Red-blonde
- Eye Color: Green
- Identity: Defenseman / best friend
Flirty, loyal, and emotionally honest — the heart of the group.
Aiden "Murph" Murphy
- Age: 29
- Hair Color: Black
- Eye Color: Hazel
- Identity: Goalie / quiet protector
Reserved but intense, his connection with Rachel is slow-burning and full of tension.
Binge Smut with Visuals on SHORTBREAD
Love Pucking Around? Watch smut brought to life on Shortbread, just like TV shows.



Every Spicy Chapter – Breakdown & Highlights
Pucking Around is long, funny, and surprisingly emotional — and its spicy moments are woven naturally into the plot. Each one builds on trust and character development, not just attraction. They show Rachel learning to feel safe, confident, and desired again after years of insecurity.
Here's how each moment actually unfolds in the story.
Chapter 21 – The First Kiss (Rachel & Jake)
Rachel and Jake have spent weeks dancing around their chemistry. She's been working closely with him on recovery sessions, always keeping it "professional," but it's clear there's something more. After a big game where Jake scores the winning goal, he catches her alone in the training room.
He's sweaty, grinning, and thanks her for helping him get back on the ice. She jokes that he did all the work, but when their eyes meet, everything shifts. Jake steps closer, cups her chin, and tells her he hasn't stopped thinking about her. Rachel starts to protest — "This is a bad idea" — but before she can finish, he kisses her.
It's slow at first, then deepens — years of pent-up tension breaking loose. She pushes him back playfully and reminds him she could get fired for this. He just smiles and says, "Then I'll make it worth it."
They don't sleep together yet, but this moment cracks the professional barrier completely.
"It was supposed to be professional, but my heart never got the memo."
Chapter 32 – The Locker Room Scene (Rachel & Jake)
After weeks of stolen looks and late-night texts, Rachel and Jake can't take it anymore. The team's gone out to celebrate, but Jake stays behind, waiting for her in the locker room.
When Rachel walks in, he's sitting on the bench, still in his half-gear. They argue — she tells him this can't happen, and he tells her it already is. The argument melts into something else when he cups her face again and says, "Tell me to stop." She doesn't.
What happens next is fast, breathless, and messy — laughter between kisses, uniforms half-off, her name whispered against her skin. The scene feels like a release for both of them after so much restraint. It's emotional, but it's also the start of something serious — after this, there's no pretending it's casual.
"He kissed me like I was something worth celebrating."
Chapter 46 – The Scotty Scene (Rachel & Scotty)
Scotty's always been Rachel's best friend on the team — the one who teases her, brings her coffee, and diffuses tension with humor. But under all that charm, he's been falling for her too.
After a brutal day dealing with rumors about her and Jake, Rachel comes home drained. Scotty shows up at her door with takeout and a bad joke. They eat, talk, and he admits he hates seeing her stressed over what people think. Then he says quietly, "You deserve to be happy, Rach — with whoever makes you feel that way."
She asks what he means, and he just leans in and kisses her. It's different from Jake — slower, softer, full of warmth instead of intensity. They end up on the couch, laughing between kisses, the moment unfolding naturally from comfort to desire.
Afterward, they don't label it — Scotty tells her, "Whatever this is, I'm okay with it — as long as you are." It's a turning point, showing that this love isn't about jealousy — it's about choice.
"With Scotty, it wasn't about fire. It was about feeling seen."
Chapter 52 – The Murph Scene (Rachel & Murph)
Murph's been the quiet one — watching from the sidelines, clearly in love but too disciplined to act on it. He's stoic, guarded, and always the one Rachel turns to when she needs grounding.
After an away game, they're alone in the hotel gym, talking about everything that's been happening. He finally cracks and admits he's been keeping his distance because he doesn't want to hurt her — or the others. She tells him he's already part of this, whether he likes it or not.
He steps closer, brushing her hair back, and says, "You sure about that?" When she nods, he kisses her — not tentative, but deliberate. The scene unfolds in his room — quiet, focused, and full of trust. He lets her set the pace until she tells him she doesn't want him to hold back.
It's intimate and emotional, the culmination of weeks of tension. Unlike Jake's fire or Scotty's laughter, Murph's love feels grounding — like something that's been waiting to happen.
"He didn't take; he gave, piece by piece, until I forgot what hurt felt like."
Chapter 60 – The Trio Scene (Rachel, Jake, Scotty & Murph)
The emotional and physical climax of the book.
Rachel's been honest with each man, but now she finally tells them she loves all three. She expects resistance, but instead, they surprise her — no jealousy, no anger. Just honesty. Jake says, "If this is what you need to be happy, then we'll figure it out."
They talk about what this means, establish boundaries, and decide they want to do it right — together. The scene that follows is passionate but respectful. Each man interacts with her in his own way — Jake's confident, Scotty's playful, Murph's steady. Rath writes it with balance and care, focusing on connection over shock value.
It's not about competition; it's about belonging. When it's over, they don't separate — they stay close, laughing, talking, and holding her like she's the heart that ties them all together.
"There was no guilt, no shame — just us, and the way we fit together."
Chapter 66 – The Morning After
The next morning is soft and domestic — sunlight through the blinds, tangled blankets, and three hockey players fighting over who makes breakfast.
Rachel wakes up nestled between Jake and Murph, with Scotty snoring on the couch. They joke, eat pancakes, and talk about what comes next — not in a panicked "what are we?" way, but like they already know they'll make it work.
The scene closes on Rachel's reflection that love doesn't have to look one way to be real — it just has to make you feel safe, seen, and wanted.
"Love didn't break me. It built me back up."
Goodreads Reader Reactions
Readers adore Pucking Around for its humor, emotional depth, and genuine portrayal of polyamory done right.
Positive Reactions:
"Finally, a why-choose romance with heart and consent — and actual hockey!"
"The spice is great, but the emotional writing is even better."
"Murph is the man of my dreams, and I won't be taking questions."
Fans loved how Emily Rath created a realistic team dynamic and gave Rachel agency throughout her journey.
Critical Reactions:
"It's long — but worth every page."
"Some scenes dragged, but the character work made it feel real."
Overall, readers praise it for balancing heat with humor and for giving every character a voice in a relationship built on respect, communication, and love.
Binge Smut with Visuals on SHORTBREAD
Love Pucking Around? Watch smut brought to life on Shortbread, just like TV shows.



Where to Buy or Read Pucking Around
- Amazon: Paperback, Kindle, and Kindle Unlimited
- Barnes & Noble: Paperback edition
- Apple Books & Kobo: eBook versions
- Libraries: Available through Libby and Hoopla
- Free with Kindle Unlimited: Read the full series digitally
Related Books – The Jacksonville Rays Series Order
Emily Rath's hockey romance universe centers on the Jacksonville Rays and the people who love them. Each book focuses on a new dynamic — teammates, therapists, and found family — but the stories overlap beautifully.
1️⃣ Pucking Around – Rachel's story and her why-choose romance with Jake, Scotty, and Murph.
2️⃣ Pucking Wild – Follows the next generation of Rays players and expands on the team's personal lives.
3️⃣ Pucking Perfect (Upcoming) – A new installment teased by Rath, featuring familiar faces and a new love triangle.
Every book mixes sports, friendship, and found-family themes — with plenty of heat and heart.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Synopsis of Pucking Around: A Why Choose Hockey Romance
It's about Rachel, a new physical therapist for a professional hockey team, who unexpectedly falls for three teammates — Jake, Scotty, and Murph. It's a story of trust, healing, and choosing love on your own terms.
Q: Who does Rachel end up with in Pucking Around?
Rachel ends up with Jake, Scotty, and Murph — all three. The story is a why-choose romance, and the relationship is built on honesty and mutual love.
Q: How does Pucking Around end?
It ends with Rachel fully embracing her polyamorous relationship, happy and secure with all three men as they build a life together.
Q: What is Pucking Around about?
It's a spicy, emotional, and empowering romance about love that doesn't have to fit convention — set in the world of professional hockey.
Q: Who does Rachel marry in Pucking Around?
Rachel doesn't officially marry anyone — but she chooses to be with all three partners, forming a committed relationship built on communication and equality.
Q: What happens in Pucking Around?
Rachel joins the Rays as their physical therapist, bonds with her players, and learns to trust again through friendship, laughter, and love — both emotional and physical.
Q: Who does Jake end up with in Pucking Around?
Jake ends up with Rachel, as part of the shared relationship with Scotty and Murph.
Q: In Pucking Around, who does Rachel end up with?
Rachel ends up with Jake, Scotty, and Murph, forming a healthy and consensual polyamorous relationship.
Q: How many books are in the Pucking Around series?
There are two books published so far — Pucking Around and Pucking Wild — with more in development.
Q: What are the spicy chapters in Pucking Around?
The main spicy chapters are 21, 32, 46, 52, 60, and 66, each escalating in intensity and emotion.
Q: Where can I read Pucking Around?
You can read it on Kindle Unlimited, or purchase it via Amazon, Apple Books, or Barnes & Noble in both digital and print editions.
Binge Smut with Visuals on SHORTBREAD
Love Pucking Around? Watch smut brought to life on Shortbread, just like TV shows.




